Monday, October 27, 2014

Nancy Walker: Feminist or Naturalist?


Nancy Walker argues that Kate Chopin’s motives behind writing The Awakening were driven by naturalist ideas rather than feminist ones. Walker claims that Edna had “little control over her own destiny, and its important to note that she is controlled by her own emotions, not by men or society”. I agree with this statement, and found her point of view on the purpose of Edna’s character to be interesting considering it is easy to assume the novel was written from a feminist point of view.
 
Although many viewed Chopin as a feminist, the ideas behind The Awakening were far beyond feminism beliefs. She takes a naturalistic approach in which Edna’s own feelings and thoughts are what drive the purpose of the novel as a whole. Interestingly enough, Walker points out that in Chopin’s novel “there is no stance about women liberation or equality”, but that this idea is influenced by the relationships of other women around Edna. I found this to be a new perspective to look at the story, considering none of Edna’s motives were in spite of other women, but rather in spite of her own, natural emotions. The feelings of wanting another man were foreign to her, and she is constantly confused by her inner, conflicting ideas playing out in her mind.  This natural feeling of sensual desire was blatant throughout the book which was a result of the neglect from Edna’s husband. However, that being said all of Edna’s “awakenings” were found when she was involved in sexual relationships with other men. For example, when Edna dreams of Robert and when she wakes, she is conflicted with her feelings between her husband and Robert. The emotional conflicts in which Edna faces throughout the novel is highly significant in the argument of Walker’s, confirming that in no part of the novel was she controlled directly by society, but rather controlled by her emotions. I think that this is important to distinguish because it is easy to conclude that her marriage and society is directly affecting her, when in reality it’s her own emotions Edna faces the most struggle with. Her emotions lead her to the desire of freedom, which is when she gets involved with other men and becomes awakened. Edna also does nothing to stop her death, which reveals that “she has not controlled her own destiny”.

            Overall, Chopin uses a naturalist approach when writing her novel, seeing that all the events in the story are a result of emotions, specifically being Edna’s. Her intellectual conflicts allow her to explore herself as a woman, and her role in the novel teaches the reader about the society and women in which she lives around.

No comments:

Post a Comment