In the short story "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas", the narrator renders the sacrifices the utopian society of Omelas gives in order for its citizens happiness. Le Guin's use of symbolism, setting and irony highlight the overall importance of individuality and following intuition.
Le Guin uses symbolism to drive her purpose of following intuition. The mention of the mountains in the distance symbolize how there is more to the world than the city of Omelas. The "ones who walked away" from Omelas, were the ones who realized that the sacrifice of the child in order for everyone else's happiness was immoral. At the end of the story it describes the people who walk away as walking directly into the mountains outside of the city, thus walking into reality. The ones who walked away were the ones who followed their intuition because they understood the ugly reality of Omelas and how in actuality, it was more of a dystopia than utopia. Individuality is an important part for those who understand the unfairness that drives the cities happiness. Le Guin specifically uses this symbol at the beginning of the story when mentioning how "perfect" the society is, to then mentioning it again when the reader understands the flaws in which the society possesses.
Ironically, by the end of the story, the reader is left with a sort of despise towards Omelas. They people of Omelas grow ignorant to the child suffering in the basement and in fact "they all know it is there... they all know it has to be there". However the irony in this is the contradiction between the happiness of the people and the unhappiness of the child. The people who are actually important to the story are the indivudials who choose to do the right thing, to walk away from Omelas. This irony helps to drive the authors purpose because it takes more individuals than followers, which the society of Omelas lacks.
The setting of Omelas is important because of its fictitious traits. Taking place during a summer festival is important because it shows on the surface the beauty of all of the people who come together during this time. The setting at the beginning differs from the end going from the beauty and uniformity of all the people, to the dark and dreary basement underneath "one of the beautiful public buildings of Omelas". The juxtaposition of beauty and ugliness plays an important part of how the setting is described and how it helps to highlight the importance of "the ones who walked away".
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
Monday, September 29, 2014
Hills Like White Elephants
In the short story "Hills Like White Elephants", Hemingway depicts the tension stirring relationship between a man and a woman. Through third person point of view, and symbolism Ernest Hemingway is able to characterize the unpredictable relationship between the two characters.
Symbolism is used throughout the book in order to represent the relationship between the man and woman. Considering majority of the story of told through dialogue, communication is a huge theme throughout the book. The symbol of the hills in the story represents the choppy communication in which the man and woman have, which relates directly to the struggles in which they face. An important piece of a relationship is communication, and without it, a relationship can be damaged. This shows Hemingway's indirect characterization of their challenging relationship and how from the beginning they are faced with many issues. Another symbol that represents lack of communication is the white elephant. The phrase "the elephant in the room" can be used as a perfect example to relate their relationship, as throughout the story the reader is able to depict that they seem to be talking about something important but never state what it really is. This characterizes their relationship in the sense that again, their communication appears to be lacking. This shows the unstable nature of their relationship, and how they seemingly are creating more problems for themselves.
The third person point of view acts as a very important role of the story. Consisting of mostly dialogue, the reader has no prior knowledge about the story. The main importance in this particular piece was really to capture the ways in which the man and woman communicated to each other. Being able to read their dialogue but not necessarily their thoughts helped the author to display their relationship in a negative light. The third person point of view showed the fragmented pieces of conversation, and the constant back and fourth between the couple. This allows the reader to interpret the negative attitude they give off, and how it effects the spiral of their relationship. Due to Hemingway's use of symbolism, and third person point of view, the relationship between the man and woman is established in a negative light. Communication is important in a healthy upbringing and stable relationship.
Tuesday, September 23, 2014
I Stand Here Ironing
In the short story “I Stand Here Ironing” by Tillie Olsen, a
woman deliberates her parenting methods and obstacles faced, especially while
raising her oldest daughter Emily. Throughout the story, Olsen uses a regretful
tone, reflective first person point of view, and various diction to accentuate the
importance of the role that parenting plays in a child’s life.
The
narrator uses a regretful tone to indicate how she feels about raising her daughter. She regrets that her “wisdom came too late”
and that as a result of this, Emily could’ve been in a lot better position if
her mother had always been there for her (Olsen 298). This is important because
the narrator is recognizing and reflecting back to Emily’s childhood and
realizing the things she could have done differently. Perhaps if she hadn’t left
Emily at a young age, she could have acquired more confidence. The first person
point of view is important to this story because it allows the reader to
understand the narrators thought process, and the challenges she faced as a
parent. She is reflecting on Emily’s entire life, and now that she is 19 years
old, the reader is able to see her thought process behind her many years of
parenting and how it had a negative effect on Emily. The diction in which the narrator
uses is very reflective and understanding. Emily’s “life was such that she had
to keep much to herself” which shows how her mother had lasting effects on her
(298). However, the narrator uses words and phrases that demonstrate her
understanding in the present of how she negatively impacted her daughter’s
state of being and how it could have been different. Parenting has an overall
huge effect on a child’s upbringing and the traits that they can end up possessing.
Sunday, September 21, 2014
Cathedral Question Responses
1. The narrator of “Cathedral” is a very straight-forward
character. He is often quick to judge, and shows the reader that he already has
impressions of the blind. His tone is very assuming, and he doesn’t like the
idea of the blind man. He is not accepting of other people, and isn’t as enthusiastic
as his wife is when the blind man comes to visit. He is very skeptical and is
very straight-forward in his tone.
2. Carver’s narrator sets up the reader to believe the same
as he does. He expects the blind man to be nothing special, and incapable. The
first actions of the blind man are very different than expected. I expected him
to be very boring, and very needy. However,
he was an extremely capable being, to the point where he was able to eat his
own dinner without help. In paragraphs 18-44 the conversation between the
narrators own thoughts shows that he is impressed too “as he used his knife and
fork on the meat” (Carver 1084). This is significant because the narrator is
already showing fascination in Roberts’s actions, something that he never
thought he would have been interested in before.
3. Blindness is shown in two different ways throughout the
story. The narrator and his wife both see it as something very differently. His
wife finds it interesting and moving, as she is very passionate in her friend Robert.
She even writes a poem about it and her interaction with him through tapes show
how it is important for her that he is part of her life. The narrator’s
negative attitude towards the blind in the beginning of the story is proved
wrong by the end of the story. This two opposing sides is very important
because it shows growth in the narrator’s character. By the end of the story,
his ideas are similar to his wives on Robert, and now he is able to fully
understand where she came from.
5. The narrator experiences an epiphany that is somewhat
unexplained. At the end, the story is open ended which is purposely written so
that the reader is able to provide insight of their own. Considering the answer
or reason behind this is never revealed, it allows the reader to come up with
more than one answer. Carver also keeps out the end result of the drawing, and
how the wife responded to it when she woke up. The author does this so that the
reader can come up with a solution.
6. The narrator and his wife are not close. Often times, she
will question what he says, or tell him how to act especially in the presence
of Robert. She is controlling over him, and wants him to act certain ways. They
don’t interact much when the blind man is even there, which shows the gap in
their relationship. Due to the fact the narrator has a negative outlook on
life, he and his wife do not have a strong relationship. Carver does not pass
judgment on characters, he gives his information very straight-forward, without
the author’s analysis especially in the areas where the narrator and his wife
are drinking and using drugs. I did not judge any character either, besides
Robert at first. I thought maybe he would be suspicious of trying to steal the narrator’s
wife from him, however I was wrong.
Thursday, September 18, 2014
Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?
In her work Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?, Joyce
Oates articulates the story of a young girl Connie, and how she struggles with lack of support from her family. Oates
expresses the importance of family, and without it, how innocence can be
corrupted and jeopardized.
Early descriptions of Connie show that she is a typical,
self-expressive fifteen year old who is often criticized by her mother, which forms
her disinterest in spending time with her family. The distance between Connie
and her family members generates her desire to be rebellious due to the fact
she cannot rely on her family for support. Everything about Connie “had two
sides to it, one from home and one for anywhere that was not home” which truly
demonstrated how dishonesty was what she lived by in terms of her relationship
with her family members (Oates 469). Connie did not consider her family to be important
to her, which eventually led to the corruption of her innocence.
As Connie is conflicted with the horrifying encounter with Arnold
Friend, it is then she realizes how important family is, and how essential
support is. The intellectual absence of a compassionate family affected her
emotionally, and mentally. However, with the physical absence of her family
while she is haunted by fear, forces Connie to think of them in a much different
way. Instead of wanting nothing to do with them, now she is constantly wondering
when they will return from the cookout, which shows a growth in Connie’s
perspective on her family. Oates uses the situation between Arnold and Connie
to drive Connie’s character forward, and express the true importance of having
a supportive and loving family.
Wednesday, September 17, 2014
Yellow Wallpaper Analysis
In "The Yellow Wallpaper",
Charlotte Perkins Gilman writes about a young woman who not only faces mental
and identity challenges, but also challenges within her relationship. She has a
hard time understanding the world around her due to her mental state, but also
has a hard time understanding herself. Throughout the story, she spends her
time in a “nursery”, fixated on the yellow wallpaper which she spends her time
trying to figure out. A few odd details unravel about the nursery, like containing
barred windows, and bolted down beds, and even scratches on the floor. From this,
it is obvious that the nursery was no former place where children played, but
rather some sort of prison or asylum for mental patients. Literally and figuratively
speaking, she is a prisoner to her own mind. Due to such instability, she has a
hard time connecting to her husband, who plays more of a guardian role than
significant other. Gilman’s purpose in including these challenges is to express
how important it is in fully understanding who you are as a person and how you
fit into society. Without an identity of your own, it is hard or nearly
impossible to contribute to the identity of a society.
Monday, September 15, 2014
The Yellow Wallpaper
1. The narrator’s change throughout the short story directly
ties into her conclusion of the yellow wallpaper at the end. At the beginning,
she is nearly recognizing the house for its beauty and potential for “romantic
felicity”, however as soon as she finds herself spending time in the nursery, her
character changes greatly (Gillman 647). She has a repulsive attitude towards
the hideous color of the yellow wallpaper, which over the story grows into an
obsessive fascination in the wallpaper itself, and what she believes to be a
woman behind it. The symbol of the woman in the wallpaper, directly relates to
the narrator herself as she describes the woman in the wall as creepy, which
she admits in the passage that she too “creep(s) by daylight” (Gillman 654). This
ties together because she ends up directly summarizing her behaviors in the
perspective of the wallpaper paper woman. Up until the ending, she is uneasy
and so eager to find what it is behind the wallpaper that by the end of the
book she is satisfied that she has finally peeled away and found what it was
she was looking for. While reading it, my feelings begin to differ from the
narrators because I feel as though by the end, in my perspective she is far
away from reality to the point where she nearly seems insane, however in her
perspective, she is content and has reached her reality of knowing what the
image was behind the wall.
2. A huge red flag
that I noticed when reading this passage was the paragraph explaining the
barred windows and scratched floors. The author references this room to be a
nursery and justifies this with noting that “the windows are barred for little
children”, however this led me to think a number of certain things (Gillman 648).
Was this building actually for children, or perhaps a mental institution? I
drew this conclusion because also the author mentions at the beginning that there
“was something queer about it. Else, why should it be so cheap?” (Gillman 647).
As the story progressed, so did the idea that it easily could be, considering
she has nervous depression, and what seems by the end of the book a more severe
mental illness. Her obsessive impulses, strange behaviors and indecisive
thoughts are also another reason to believe this to be true. She is constantly
talking back and forth with herself, and also going from a positive mood of the
house, to the faults in her relationship, to the faults in herself dealing with
her depression. Considering she seems to be unstable, and very moody, it could
be possible she maybe not only has depression but perhaps a bipolar or multiple
personality disorder of some sort, which again leads the reader to believe that
this building was in fact more than just a nursery.
4. The descriptions that the author uses to describe the
wallpaper in these paragraphs, reveals the frustration in which she had in trying
to understand it. She puts much effort and deep thought into analyzing the
wallpaper itself. She states that she “know a little of the principle of design”
which suggests that she has to do her own thoughts in interpreting it (Gillman
651). She is looking for a conclusion within the patterns and aesthetics of the
paper, however she is not yet reaching it but rather “it makes [her] tired to
follow it” (Gillman 651). This shows the longing and tedious process in which
leads her to the ending of the story. It mirrors the pattern on the wall paper,
because it is repetitive, just like the syntax in between paragraphs 96-101. Her
explanation is dragged out into an array of thoughts, and so is the entire
story until she reaches her satisfying conclusion.
Monday, September 8, 2014
Symbols Symbols Symbols!
In Hurston’s novel, Their
Eyes Were Watching God, one of the most important themes is gender and how Janie
walks through life dealing with the power of gender working against her. How to
Read Literature Like a Professor stresses the importance of symbols, and
how to exactly figure out what it is an author is trying to say when using them. Hurston uses symbols to expand on the major
themes of the book, but also to show Janie’s character growth.
Hurston consistently used the symbols of nature, as many
mentions of nature were brought about throughout the novel. Mentions of the pear tree, the sun (and
horizon), and other little mentions of nature, symbolize Janie’s constant daydream
of hope and love. Most significant to
Janie was the pear tree considering that’s where she would spend her time
thinking about love and marriage and how “husbands and wives always loved each other,
and that’s what marriage meant” (Hurston 25). The sun symbolized Janie’s hope,
and how her hope was eventually reached by the end of the novel. At first, the mention of the sun on the first
page was a symbol of Janie’s far reaching anticipation out on the horizon. By the end of the novel, Janie had “pulled in
her horizon like a great fish-net”, essentially saying she now has a handle on
life and is at peace with it (Hurston 227).
The most important symbol is Janie’s hair and head rags,
which symbolize the message that relationships are important, and so is how one
builds them. Janie is constricted to
male power, and when “she tore off the kerchief from her head and let down her
plentiful hair”, a new meaning to this symbol arose; freedom (Hurston 104). This liberating moment was important to her growth in character and brought her closer to finding her way into society. This
is important to the purpose of Hurston’s novel because this shows how not only
was Janie searching for love, but she was also searching for herself.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)